Skip to Content

Electric Smoker Vs Pellet Smoker: Which Is Better?

Many people have questioned the difference between electric smokers and pellet smokers. People have known of the electric smoker for many years, but it is still very new to the market.

On the other hand, pellet smokers have been around long enough so that there are a lot more choices for this type of smoker.

You can certainly cook pork, beef, a smoke ring, chicken, vegetables, and many more food items on different types of smokers.

Either one of these smokers is a great investment for getting the best results on your food. Many use these for outdoor cooking and at events.

Can these two types of smokers be interchanged? Are they even comparable at all? We’re going to see how these two compare with each other in various elements.

What is an Electric Smoker?

An electric smoker is a type of machine that uses electricity to cook meat. As the name suggests, it was invented by George Stephen, which he called the “electric smoke-cooker”.

Today’s technology has come a long way since then and you can do much more than just smoke with an electric element.

Electric models of smokers have a temperature range you can set for your food from the digital controller on it. The source of heat comes from a hot electric heating rod.

Compared to a charcoal smoker, propane smokers, and a gas grill, the Pit Boss is the best smoker that is easier and cleaner to operate.

A masterbuilt digital electric smoker does not need a bag of pellets to heat up but rather uses the cooking chamber to heat up.

What are the Benefits of an Electric Smoker?

The biggest benefit of using an electric smoker is that you don’t have to tend to it while cooking.

Traditional smokers require constant supervision so that no one raises the temperature too high, which causes burning or drying out of your food.

When using an electric smoker, all you have to do is set the timer and let it go. The longer you smoke, the better your food will be – no supervision required!

The best electric smokers have an electric unit with a digital panel with precise temperature control. If you are ona tight budget electric smokers are more budget-friendly.

What are the Drawbacks of an Electric Smoker?

Since electricity is running through the machine, it can be a hazard if it were to malfunction.

Also, since the temperature is pre-programmed and mostly unregulated, you’ve stuck with whatever temperature that programmable electric smoker offers.

Of course, this also means that you cannot adjust for cold climates such as cold smoking or low and slow smoking for stronger flavors in your food.

What is a Pellet Smoker?

A pellet smoker is a type of smoker that uses compressed wood chunks or pellets to heat and smoke the food. It functions in a similar way as an electric smoker, but it can be modified much more.

Some pellet smokers have a fire pot that is used to ignite and warm up the pellets. The good news is that many don’t need one of these they already have one built-in.

Traeger grills show how a pellet smoker work and the ounces of wood you may need. Pellet smokers don’t need a power outlet to heat up.

What are the Benefits of a Pellet Smoker?

The advantages of using this type of smoker over an electric model or other types are that you have total control over temperature. You can even use it indoors without having to worry about carbon monoxide build-up!

Unlike traditional smokers, pellet smokers give you great flexibility to change temperatures throughout your cooking process. Also, since there isn’t a constant heat source being used, you have less chance of burning your food or drying it out.

Many pellet smokers have digital control panels that make it an excellent choice. The best pellet grills allow you to maintain a low and steady temperature for hours.

The low temperatures of wood pellet smokers allow you to cook your food just the way you like it. The best pellet smokers are stainless steel with applewood pellets.

The best choice is the ones that have all the controls in the bottom of the cooking chamber. They also include a sear box to vaporize the dripping grease.

At the right temperature and pounds of pellets, this kind of smoker leaves traditional grills and a woody flavor. You can even add a water pan to lower the temperatures if needed and allow water vapor to disperse.

What are the Drawbacks of a Pellet Smoker?

Pellet smokers are more expensive than traditional smokers.

Also, pellet smokers are not exactly known for producing high-temperature steaks or other types of meat that you would normally cook on a grill.

The better option is to go with a Z grill that has digital temperature controls in degrees fahrenheit and have an auger motor.

To solve this problem, you can still set the temperature too high. That will give you some great grill marks without overcooking your food! It does take some trial and error to get it right though.

What is the Difference Between an Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker?

The big difference is an electric smoker simply uses electricity as its fuel source while a pellet smoker burns through wood pellets (which may contain different flavors).

A pellet smoker can take hardwood pellets, real wood, and traditional wood for a smokey flavor. A wood pellet grill is a better choice since it has a wood chip tray.

Another major difference is an electric smoker produces heat, steam, and smoke while a pellet smoker produces heat, lots of smoke, and the combustion process.

With that in mind, when looking at benefits and drawbacks, there really isn’t much of a difference between the two. They will both take a long time to cook your food, and they will both require supervision during cooking.

In general, it is recommended that you use one of these smokers if you have never tried smoking before because they are less dangerous than traditional smokers and easier to use overall.

However, if you already have a smoker or grill that works for you, then there’s no need to try out a new type!

Where is each type of smoker best used?

This is a question that you should ask yourself before purchasing any type of outdoor cooking appliance.

We will start by looking at the electric smokers vs pellet smokers from the perspective of someone who already knows which one they want, but still needs to find out where each one would make most sense for their situation.

Both types of smokers are basically designed for use outside in your backyard or on your patio. They are great for a camp chef as well.

It does not matter whether you live in a house, apartment, condo, whatever it may be, as long as you have a spot in your yard that can accommodate a BBQ-capable grill, you can use either type.

What about in a state park or a public location where grills are not allowed? Not to worry! You will be able to avoid this problem by going with a portable smoker that runs on propane.

This is because propane is much easier and safer to use when cooking away from home.

These types of small smokers might not have all the bells and whistles as their larger counterparts, but they do provide excellent results in a short amount of time.

An offset smoker is the best option if you are wanting to stick with a natural wood fire and higher temperatures.

Pros and Cons Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker

Now, let’s look at the two types side-by-side so that you can get an idea of which one would work best for your situation. Remember that there are pros and cons to both electric smokers vs pellet smokers.

The electric smoker is a little bit more difficult to use than the pellet smoker. You have to monitor the moisture levels inside by opening up the door which lets heat escape and prolongs cooking time.

On top of that, you have to wait for it to heat up before you can cook with it. Unlike a pellet smoker which does not require any preheating time!

These kinds of things aren’t too big of an issue if you just want food ready to eat in a shorter span of cook time. But they are still something that you should consider when choosing between electric smokers vs pellet smokers.

As far as using your machine outdoors goes, both types will work fine on some level. The propane smoker will work better in this case because it has the ability to be free-standing.

You just hook up your propane tank that comes with the smoker, turn on the gas supply and you are ready to start cooking!

If you want an electric smoker vs pellet smoker that can also handle outdoor use, you will have some limitations which we go over below.

The Cooking Process

Now that you have an idea of where each one will work best, let’s take a look at the cooking process behind how electric smokers vs pellet smokers work.

The main principle for both devices is that they are used to slow cook food by placing it far away from high heat and allowing smoke to be passed over your meat.

Although this concept is the same in both types (and most outdoor cookers), there are some key differences when it comes down to what is actually happening inside when you use them.

Electric smokers require you to add wood chips occasionally in order for food to get smoky and flavorful as barbecue should be!

On the other hand, pellet smokers have a built-in mechanism that allows you to connect a hopper full of wood pellets and allow them to slowly burn like the flame from the heating element below heats up.

You can think of these kinds of smokers as sophisticated crockpots! They work by simply allowing heat and smoke to do all the hard work, so your job is pretty easy.

If you are unsure if your meat is cooked the way you want I suggest you get a meat probe to check the temperature to ensure its fully cooked.

The Many Options of the Electric Smoker

Electrical smokers come in a wide variety of sizes and can serve many purposes which is one of the main differences. The square inches of each smoker varies on the type you are looking for.

While they typically provide ease of use, their electric heating elements also offer greater control over heat and cooking time.

For instance, some models feature adjustable thermostats. This allows users to better regulate cooking temperatures as well as internal moisture levels.

Though older styles of electrical smokers were more rudimentary than those available today, the modernized options incorporate such features as programmable timers for unattended smoking.

In addition to stand-alone smokers, many brands also produce grill/smoker combos that take up only minimal space on your deck or patio!

A Guide To Using A Pellet Smoker

While the initial in a pellet smoker may seem more complicated than that of an electric smoker, there are some key differences to take note of.

Z grills and Charcoal grills have a storage container to keep everything together. Among those, there are the best vertical pellet smokers. The best thing about these is the vertical design and power source from within.

First, make sure you are using a pellet grill rather than an electric one. Pellets are larger and come in bags that should be stored out of reach from children or pets! Also, make sure you have enough ventilation around your grill.

Pellet smokers work best when they are allowed to cook at very high temperatures for long periods of time. This makes them ideal for smoking large pieces of meat like pork shoulders or turkey legs.

On the other hand, if you want to slow-cook something like ribs or brisket, then this is not the type of smoker to use! To begin cooking with your pellet smoker, load it with wood pellets and set the temperature on ‘high’ for an hour or so before you add your food.

By doing this you will burn off any residue that might have been leftover from the manufacturing process. If not it cause a bitter taste in your meat if it is not removed. You can then lower the temperature to around 225 degrees F and leave it for as long as it takes to smoke your food!

Electric Smokers Vs Pellet Smokers – Which One Should I Choose?

Well, now that we understand how each device works, let’s take a look at some of its pros and cons! Remember though, these are all things that you should consider before buying something new. Make sure they fit with what you want to do with them.

Pros of using an Electric Smoker

Can cook many different types of food, including fish and vegetables!

Temperature is easy to control.

They are generally cheaper than pellet smokers! Plus, you can often find good deals on them if you look online or in the Sunday paper.

Cons of using an electric smoker:

You need to constantly check it and adjust the wood chips if necessary. Some people like this though. It means they get to know their equipment well and make small adjustments as needed. Others find it annoying because there is not much time for socializing when tending the smoker all day long! The choice is up to you.

Pros of using a Pellet Smoker    

They are automatic so you don’t need to monitor them as closely, and it is easy to get started!

They are portable, which means you can take them with you to go camping, tailgating, or on the boat.

Most pellet smokers come with an integrated temperature gauge, which is useful if you want to try cooking at different temperatures.

Cons of using a pellet smoker:

The pellets themselves cost around $4/pound which adds up if you plan on consuming more than a few pounds each time you smoke something.

The flavor is not as good as that of wood or charcoal. This might be important for you if, like me, you are used to cooking with those.

It can be hard to find a pellet smoker for under $500, which is one of the reasons they are so expensive.

The Bottom Line on Electric Smoker vs Pellet Smoker

So, what’s our final take on electric smokers vs pellet smokers?

As far as choosing between an electric smoker vs pellet smoker, it really comes down to a couple of factors. How often are you going to be using your machine?

If you plan on using your smoker multiple times per week or even daily, go for the electric smoker. This is because you will be able to prepare food faster. It allows you to keep an eye on how things are going at all times.

If you plan on only using your machine once in a while (or even just for special occasions), definitely choose pellet smokers! This is because they are set-it-and-forget-it devices that work very well without requiring much oversight from the user.

What type of cooking do you prefer?

If you think that barbecue flavored meat tastes better than oven-cooked food, consider getting an electric smoker.

These types of machines allow for hands-on operation so that users can put various woods chips into the smoking chamber whenever they want to achieve different flavors based on their preference.

If you like to cook food indoors and want the flavor of barbecue, go with a pellet smoker. Since it burns wood pellets internally, users can expect that smoky flavor without having to worry about adding wood chips every few hours!

So, make sure you keep these things in mind as you choose between electric smokers vs pellet smokers! Although there are many similarities between the two types, they still have their own distinct advantages that may be more suited for your particular cooking needs.

Intake fans or a convection fan for small space smokers helps with the smoke and indirect heat.

The choice is yours – just think about how often you will use your machine, what kind of food and flavors you prefer, and how much money you want to spend on an outdoor cooker before making a final decision!

Get the scoop on more like this:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.