Skip to Content

Top 10 Hallmark Mystery Movies

From plot twists to thrilling cliffhangers, Hallmark mystery movies are the place to be! There is nothing like a a movie night full of mystery, suspense, and also murder!

So, here’s the scoop on the top 10 Hallmark mystery movies you need to watch right now!

Martha’s Vineyard Mysteries

Martha's Vineyard Mysteries, Hallmark
2020 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Allister Foster

This Hallmark mystery takes place at an art gallery where a robbery takes place! Also, there is a murder on the premises! Now, it’s up to Jeff W. Jackson, a former detective, and Dr. Zee Madieras to find out who the culprit is!

Crossword Mysteries Terminal Descent

Cross Word Mysteries, Hallmark
2021 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Allister Foster

Supercomputers thrive in the future and Tess Harper, played by Lacey Chabert, lands a volunteer opportunity to take part in a crossword competition. Through this, she also manages to wind up in an investigation to find out who murdered a tech CEO!

Wedding Planner Mystery

Wedding Planner Mystery, Hallmark
2014 Crown Media United States, LLC/Photographer: Bettina Strauss

Erica Durance stars in this Hallmark mystery as Carnegie Kincaid, a wedding planner who has been framed for murder and is now a top suspect! While she tries to clear her name from suspicion, she thinks someone is out to get her! Someone who actually committed the crime!

Hailey Dean Mystery: Murder, with Love

Hailey Dean, Hallmark
2016 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Sergei Bachlakov

This film brings to you a Hallmark homicide! Hailey Dean is a prosecutor and now a therapist. One of her patients is suspected to be involved in a homicide and is under investigation! Hailey Dean however, believes her patient to be innocent. Now, her experience with law enforcement must be put to good use to bring justice!

Beverly Lewis’ The Reckoning

The Reckoning, Hallmark
2015 Crown Media United States, LLC/Photographer: Chris Large

Katie Mayfield is a young Amish woman who has left her small town to marry a businessman and live a more modern life in the mysterious estate passed down to her from her mother! When an old lover returns, she must choose between her old Amish life and her newly formed one! Find out in this Hallmark mystery!

Mystery 101 Playing Dead

Mystery 101 Playing Dead, Hallmark
2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ricardo Hubbs

Bella, a theater star, was nearly shot at while performing on stage by a real gun that was thought to be a prop! The theater has now become a crime scene that is under investigation. Now, it is up to Professor Amy, who teaches Crime Fiction, and Detective Travis to find out who almost took Bella’s life!

Deadly Deed A Fixer Upper Mystery

Deadly Deed A Fixer Upper Mystery, Hallmark
2018 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Kailey Schwerman

Shannon Hughes is a renovation expert who stumbles upon a dead boy while working on her newest renovation! The body just so happens to be the President of a bank nearby in the city of Lighthouse Cove. Shannon works with Mac Sullivan, a writer, to uncover the true murderer as suspects on this case are unusually increasing!

Framed for Murder A Fixer Upper Mystery

Framed For Murder A Fixer Upper Mystery, Hallmark
2016 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ryan Plummer

Shannon Hughes is back in this fairly new Hallmark mystery and this time she is working to find the culprit who murdered a close friend of hers! Her new client and well-known crime reporter team up to uncover this mystery and the millions of dollars that may have been left behind…if they can find it!

Jane Doe Vanishing Act

Jane Doe Vanishing Act, Hallmark
2012 Crown Media, United States

After boarding a government-owned spacecraft, a scientist aboard vanishes leaving behind no clues as to what might have happened to him! Cathy Davis goes under the code name “Jane Doe” to find out what happened to the unlucky passenger in this thrilling Hallmark mystery!

Picture Perfect Mysteries Newlywed and Dead

Picture Perfect Mysteries Newlywed and Dead, Hallmark
2019 Crown Media United States LLC/Photographer: Ryan Plummer

Allie is a photographer working at a wedding when the groom is suddenly shot during the couple’s first dance! The bride’s ex-boyfriend happens to be Allie’s brother, who becomes the immediate suspect! Sam, a detective, is hired to investigate the case, but Allie forms plans of her own to make sure her brother’s name is cleared. Who will be the culprit in this Hallmark showdown?

For more Hallmark scoop check out Ryan Paevey Gushes About Co-Star Erin Cahil and Talks Hallmark Success and Interview: Neal Bledsoe from Hallmark Channel’s “A Christmas Carousel”

Check out Hallmark merchandise and gift essentials!

!function(w,i,d,g,e,t){d.getElementById(i)||(element=d.createElement(t),element.id=i,element.src=”https://widgets.rewardstyle.com”+e,d.body.appendChild(element)),w.hasOwnProperty(g)===!0&&”complete”===d.readyState&&w[g].init()}(window,”shopthepost-script”,document,”__stp”,”/js/shopthepost.js”,”script”)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Top 10 Hallmark Mystery Movies