Skip to Content

Top 10 Places to Get a Scoop of Ice Cream in New York

There are over 20,000 restaurants in New York City alone; that’s not even including the rest of the state. Imagine how many great ice cream locations there are in that huge amount of eating places; we know, basically heaven on earth.

No need to worry about trying to narrow the options to grab a sweet treat alone. We’ve got the scoop on at least 10 of those fantastic ice cream locations in New York.

1. Blue Marble Ice Cream

Founded by two friends, Blue Marble is one of the leading producers of quality organic ice cream. The company focuses on making tasty sweet treats that leaves minimal negative impacts on the planet. The standards are higher here, so don’t be surprised when the taste of it is unlike anything you’ve tasted before! With nine flavors currently for sale, there’s no reason not to love this outstanding business.

186 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238 | Website

2. Gannon’s Isle

This quirky shop began as a small stand in the parking lot of a grocery store. Gannon’s consistently wins Best Ice Cream in the Syracuse Times, so you know it’s one of the best! Over the years, this store has created over 200 insanely good flavors. Each batch is handmade in the stores, so expect a refreshing scoop when you stop by.

4800 McDonald Rd #6, Syracuse, NY 13215 | Website

3. Emack & Bolio’s

This eccentric ice cream store is like no other! With over 100 unconventional flavors, you’ll never be bored at Emack and Bolio’s. Their famous flavored cones are covered with toppings like marshmallows, fruit loops, and oreos! Everyone is sure to have a rockin’ time at this 70s themed ice cream parlor.

366 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209  | Website

4. Martha’s Dandee Creme

This traditional parlor has a simple goal: great ice cream and great service. It sounds obvious, but once you step into Martha’s, you’ll see that they take this goal quite seriously. Be prepared to be waited on by the friendliest staff and served the best you’ve ever tasted. Sometimes, it’s the simple things in life that make the biggest difference, and Martha’s has perfected the simplicity of running a wonderful parlor.

1133 U.S. 9, Queensbury, NY 12804 | Website

5. Ice and Vice

Ice and Vice works against the traditional grain and aims to do this daily. They change their menu regularly with new flavors that they are experimenting with and they are consistently amazing! This ice cream shop is adamant about being inclusive for everyone. They provide soy milk options for some of their ice cream and no egg options for their cones too. They even have ice cream sandwiches and pies that are also to die for!

221 E. Broadway, New York, NY 10002 | Website

6. The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory is one of the best sweet treat shops in New York City. Located in the heart of Chinatown it is perfect for tourists and locals alike. With flavors like lychee and taro, they aim to maintain many traditional Chinese flavors, but they also don’t exclude traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla. They have been making fantastic ice cream with a variety of flavors sine 1978. So, next time you’re in Chinatown, don’t forget to grab a scoop at this awesome spot.

65 Bayard St, New York, NY 10013 | Website

7. Ice Scream

At many ice cream shops, the ice cream is prepared in large quantities at the beginning of the day, not here, though! At Ice Scream, they prepare your batch of ice cream right in front of you. With interesting concoctions and bright colors, it’s a great place for a scoop of your favorite treat for any occasion. It’s a wonderful place to host a birthday party or just looking for a place to cool down on a hot day. They also offer nitrogen ice cream if you’re looking for a way to live you’re childhood dreams of being a dragon and making smoke blow out of your nose!

200 Baychester Ave. #129a, The Bronx, NY 10475 | Website

8. PeNGUIN Ice Cream and Snack Bar

With more than 50 years of experience, this place aims to keep you coming back. PeNGUIN Ice Cream and Snack Bar makes every order as they come in with a huge variety of flavors and mix-ins. They only make soft serve but the variety of flavors makes it worth it even for those who prefer other types. The staff is personable and aim to make you feel comfortable and important. Along with their great sweet treat options, they offer a food menu if you’re in the mood for food after your amazing dessert!

11181 NY-8, Masonville, NY 13804 | Website

9. Schoolhouse Creamery

This home style ice cream shop is a must when visiting New York. Located in the small town of Windsor, Schoolhouse Creamery provides desks to eat your cold treat in. There are picnic tables outside to be able to enjoy your treat in great weather. This shop is located in an old one room schoolhouse and is perfect to take the kids and adults alike for an amazing treat. They even make ice cream cake for all of those special occasions where something this sweet is a necessity!

17 Fox Farm Rd, Windsor, NY 13865 | Website

10. Amy’s

This ice cream shop might be located in the middle of nowhere, but it’s being talked about everywhere. Amy’s serves great ice cream with great service. The servings are huge and pair well with all of the snack food on their seemingly endless menu. Their prices are reasonable and they aim to keep you coming back. So, the next time you’re passing through New York country side, make sure you stop by this great ice cream shop for an amazing treat.

2717 NY-145, Schoharie, NY 12157 | Website

And make sure to check out the Best Ice Cream Spots in the U.S. to Satisfy your Sweet Tooth because no matter where you are, ice cream is a necessity!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

What To Serve With Bloody Mary Recipe - SARAH SCOOP EATS

Tuesday 10th of January 2023

[…] Also, New York City, aka The Big Apple, was where the famous bloody mary recipe originated. Something to think about while you’re munching on them! […]

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.